Vs comparison
MyStubs vs ThePayStubs
Established paystub-generator brand with a long-running template library and broad form coverage.
Honest comparisons
MyStubs vs other paystub generators.
We named what each competitor does well, not just where we win. Pricing as of 2026-06-01 — public pricing can change, so click through to each competitor's site for the current number before deciding.
Pick a comparison
Choose the competitor you're weighing.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PayStubHero
Branded paystub generator known for an opinionated template-first UI.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PaystubsNow
Mid-priced paystub generator with broad template coverage.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs MakePaystubPro
Budget-tier paystub generator with a simple one-page checkout.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PayStubDirect
Direct-to-PDF paystub generator with minimal UI.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs Gusto
Full-service payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small and mid-sized businesses with employees on payroll.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs ADP Run
Small-business arm of ADP, the largest U.S. payroll provider — full-service payroll + tax filing + HR add-ons.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs QuickBooks Payroll
Intuit's payroll add-on for QuickBooks Online users — payroll integrated with the accounting platform most small businesses already use.